Grading Guides

CGC is now the main alternative to PSA, SGC and Beckett

Collectors' three grading brands handled about 71% of August grading volume, according to CNBC citing GemRate. CGC had about 28%. If you used SGC or Beckett as a hedge against PSA, that hedge now shares PSA's owner. This piece covers what changed and how to choose a label for your next submission.

PureGrail Editorial11 min read
Extreme close-up of the corner of a graded card slab on dark felt, with raking light catching the acrylic edge and a holographic swirl-patterned card inside, the label strip blurred.

In August 2026, Collectors Holdings' three grading brands (PSA, SGC and Beckett) handled roughly 71% of grading volume among the major firms GemRate tracks, CNBC reported on November 6, citing GemRate. PSA alone had about 65%. CGC had about 28%. If you searched "PSA SGC Beckett same owner," the answer is yes, and that changes how you should think about where to send cards and which slabs to buy.

For years, collectors treated SGC and Beckett as the hedge against PSA. They were usually cheaper, sometimes faster, and run by someone else. The cheap and fast parts have mostly gone, and so has the separate owner. CGC is the only grader of real scale outside the Collectors group.

How PSA, SGC and Beckett ended up under one owner

Collectors bought SGC in February 2024, according to the antitrust complaint as reported by Value Added Resource and Collectors' own motion papers. On December 15, 2025, Collectors announced a definitive agreement to acquire Beckett. The release said Beckett "will remain an independent brand within the Collectors family of companies." CEO Nat Turner said Beckett "will continue to operate as its own independent brand" and added, "The first card I ever submitted for grading was to Beckett."

Three graded card slabs stand on a dark shelf seen from above at an angle, two pressed together and one set apart, with a closed shipping box at the end.

Separate brands still don't make separate businesses. A collector who holds PSA, SGC and Beckett slabs has exposure to one parent company's pricing decisions, capacity limits and legal risk.

SGC went from value option to boutique brand

In July 2025, Collectors said it would scale SGC down. PSA President Ryan Hoge, who was also acting as SGC's president, said SGC would become a "boutique" grading brand. SI reported that SGC's volume then fell from 143k cards in July 2025 to 112k in August and 56k in September 2025.

A year later the brand is smaller still. GemRate's August 2026 count, as reported by CardGrade, put SGC at 42k cards, down 64% year over year. September came in at 46k, down 24% year over year, per CardGrade's September recap.

The price moved the other way. On September 2, 2026, SGC raised its lowest rate from $18 to $50, with an estimated turnaround of more than 40 business days, SI reported. SGC said the increase was "in response to rapidly increasing demand and continued expansion of estimated turnaround times." It also told SI that submissions were up 24% and orders up 27%, with about 2,000 new submitters since July 1, 2026. Those figures come from SGC and haven't been independently checked. Even if they're accurate, a $50 floor isn't a budget option.

Beckett had a rough summer and fall

Beckett graded 159k cards in August, up 147% year over year (CardGrade, citing GemRate), so demand was there. Capacity and operations struggled to keep up:

  • August 5, 2026: Beckett paused its Base (75+ business days) and Standard (45 business days) tiers, citing submissions up 102% year over year, Card Grading News reported. Express (15 business days) and Priority (5) stayed open.

  • September 9, 2026: Beckett took its websites and app offline, per Card Grading News. A temporary form listed Base at $17.95, Standard at $34.95 and Express at $79.95.

  • October 2, 2026: Beckett said, as quoted by CardGrade: "During planned updates to modernize our legacy IT systems, we detected suspicious technical activity" and "out of caution, took our platforms offline."

  • October 15, 2026: accounts, the Online Submission Center (US/EU), pop reports and BGS/BAS cert lookup came back, CardGrade reported. The Price Guide, Marketplace, Dealer Admin, Beckett Authentication Services and app updates were left for later phases with no dates.

For about five weeks, nobody could look up a BGS cert online. If you buy BGS slabs, verifying a cert is part of due diligence, so that gap mattered. Beckett also wasn't included in GemRate's September results, which means you can't compare September totals directly with August.

PSA's capacity squeeze explains some of the spillover

According to CNBC, PSA raised Value Bulk from $21.99 to $24.99 and Value from $27.99 to $32.99 in February. Four Value tiers were paused effective June 2, 2026 (Card Grading News), and Value reopened on October 29. CNBC reported PSA's backlog at 7.2 million items on October 20, down from 12.4 million in July. In an October 28 statement quoted by CNBC, Hoge, now president of PSA and grading at Collectors, said: "We have added an incredible amount of capacity, but we still have work to do." PSA did not respond to CNBC's detailed questions.

PSA still graded 2.20M cards in August, down 12% from July and up 32% year over year, out of 3.40M in total (CardGrade, citing GemRate). PSA, Beckett and SGC together account for roughly 2.40M of that total, which is consistent with CNBC's 71% figure.

CGC: the independent option at scale, with a long wait

CGC graded a record 937k cards in August, up 9% from July and up 114% year over year. That count includes about 65,000 semi-rigid AUTH cards, which were authenticated rather than graded, so part of the record is authentication volume. September set another record at 962k, including roughly 60k AUTH cards.

A graded card slab lit by a hard rim light stands on dark slate beside stacked small shipping boxes, packing tape and a blank calendar grid with an unattended pen.

Price is CGC's advantage. A CGC notice posted March 10, 2026 set US card Bulk at $17 and Economy at $20 for forms completed on or after March 24, 2026. The catch is the wait. On September 2, SI reported CGC Bulk at $17 per card with a 25-card minimum and a 150 working-day turnaround. That's roughly seven months of business days before the cards come back, and turnaround can change, so check CGC's current estimate before you ship.

TAG is the other independent, but it's small and costs more at the entry level. It set its own record of 58k in August and graded 50k in September. SI listed TAG's cheapest rate at $150 for 5 business days.

The resale gap is the real cost of choosing CGC

CNBC reviewed PriceCharting records and found that on September 29, 2026, a 1999 Base Set Charizard in a PSA 9 sold for about $3,440 on eBay. A CGC 9 of the same card sold the same day for about $1,890. That's one pair of sales, not an index. The gap on your card at your grade could be wider, narrower or close to nothing.

Both sources CNBC quoted framed the choice the same way. "It really all comes down to secondary market values," said Geoff Wilson, founder and CEO of CardsHQ. An Oxley Grading spokesperson said: "PSA's lead comes from resale demand and liquidity, and other labels are still building that."

That's why submission choice is an arithmetic problem. A $17 CGC grade instead of a $24.99 PSA Value Bulk grade saves about $8 per card. It only pays off if the resale discount on your specific card is smaller than the fee difference plus whatever the longer wait costs you.

The antitrust case is still at the motions stage

In Rasmussen v. Collectors Holdings, Inc. et al. (C.D. Cal. No. 8:26-cv-00897), filed the week of April 13, 2026, plaintiffs sued Collectors, PSA, SGC and Beckett. They're asking the court to order Collectors to divest SGC and BGS. The complaint alleges that after the SGC deal, Collectors raised SGC prices 20% and lengthened turnaround by as much as 400%. It also alleges that before the acquisitions PSA had about 72% of the market, CGC about 18%, SGC about 5% and BGS about 3%, and that Collectors controls about 80% afterward. Collectors argues those figures only count four companies. None of these allegations has been proven.

Collectors moved to dismiss and to compel arbitration on June 8, 2026. Its lawyers wrote that "The Complaint is long on rhetoric but devoid of substance" and called the deals "two small, unremarkable acquisitions," Value Added Resource reported. An amended complaint filed in August added plaintiffs Erick Azarian and Andrew Fedynyshyn, added California Unfair Competition Law claims, and alleged that SGC's monthly volume fell from about 150k in July to about 50k by October 2025. Collectors filed renewed arbitration and dismissal motions on September 21, 2026. Value Added Resource reported on September 23 that a hearing was set for December 11, 2026 before Judge John W. Holcomb, and that there had been no ruling.

Separately, Rep. Pat Ryan (D-NY) asked the FTC to investigate the SGC and Beckett acquisitions, saying Collectors has "consolidated over 80% of grading volume," Value Added Resource reported in December 2025. VAR reported that the FTC had not responded. Neither the lawsuit nor the letter should drive your buying decisions this week. They're background.

What to do with your next submission

  • Price each label by expected net proceeds. Pull recent sold comps for your card at each realistic grade on PSA and CGC. Enter them with your actual fees and shipping into the card grading break-even calculator. The tool only compares the costs and prices you enter. It doesn't predict grades, current prices or returns.

  • Use CGC Bulk where the PSA premium is small and you can wait. For modern cards where PSA and CGC comps sit close together, a $17 Bulk grade can make sense if you're fine without the cards for months. For cards with a wide label gap, like the Charizard comp above, the savings on fees can disappear quickly.

  • Value SGC and Beckett slabs on their own comps. Don't assume they track PSA at a discount. Look up sold prices for that label and grade. For BGS, confirm the cert lookup works before you pay.

  • Check each grader's live service page before you ship. PSA, SGC and Beckett all paused or repriced tiers this year. What was open last month may not be open now.

For most submissions, the decision now comes down to PSA versus CGC on price, wait and resale. SGC and Beckett are niche options owned by the same parent as PSA. Our guides to reading sold comps and to deciding whether a $30 card is worth slabbing cover the next step.

Sources

Note: This article contains AI-assisted content and has been reviewed in our editorial workflow.

DISCLAIMER: PureGrail articles are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, or legal advice. Collectibles are speculative assets and values can decrease significantly. Always conduct your own research before buying or selling. Past price performance does not indicate future results.

Share this
Share

Frequently asked questions

Are PSA, SGC and Beckett owned by the same company?

Yes. Collectors Holdings owns PSA, bought SGC in February 2024, and announced a definitive agreement to acquire Beckett on December 15, 2025. CNBC now counts all three among Collectors' grading brands.

Is CGC owned by Collectors?

No. Based on GemRate's August 2026 counts as reported by CNBC and CardGrade, CGC is the only grader of real scale outside Collectors. It handled about 28% of August grading volume.

How much does SGC grading cost now?

SI reported that SGC raised its lowest rate from $18 to $50 effective September 2, 2026, with an estimated turnaround of more than 40 business days.

Do CGC slabs sell for less than PSA slabs?

Often, yes. In one same-day comp cited by CNBC, a 1999 Base Set Charizard sold for about $3,440 in a PSA 9 and about $1,890 in a CGC 9. That's a single example, so check sold comps for your own card and grade.

What is the status of the antitrust lawsuit against Collectors?

Rasmussen v. Collectors Holdings was amended in August 2026. Value Added Resource reported in September that Collectors' renewed motions to dismiss and compel arbitration were set for a December 11, 2026 hearing, with no ruling yet. The allegations are unproven.

The Newsletter

Keep pulling smart.

Weekly market moves, grading tips, auction highlights.

Keep reading

More in Grading Guides

DISCLAIMER: PureGrail articles are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, or legal advice. Collectibles are speculative assets and values can decrease significantly. Always conduct your own research before buying or selling. Past price performance does not indicate future results.