Market Analysis

A Dated Timeline of the PSA Antitrust Lawsuit Over SGC and Beckett

Collectors filed renewed motions on Sept. 21 to dismiss the PSA antitrust lawsuit and to force individual arbitration, and a Dec. 11 hearing was reported. Nothing has been decided on the merits. The timeline below sets Collectors' deal-day promises beside what the complaint alleges.

PureGrail Editorial13 min read
Illustrated night-time collector's desk with three graded slabs on a dark felt riser, an open binder page of sleeved foil cards, a loupe and a lamp casting a warm pool of light into indigo shadow.

On Sept. 21, 2026, Collectors Holdings, PSA's parent company, filed renewed motions to dismiss the PSA antitrust lawsuit and to compel each named plaintiff into individual arbitration. On Sept. 23, Value Added Resource reported that the motions are scheduled for a Dec. 11 hearing in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. No court has ruled on any motion in the case, and no court has found that Collectors broke antitrust law. Every market-share, price and turnaround figure that comes from the complaint is an allegation, and we label it that way throughout.

Where the case stands

The case is Michael Rasmussen v. Collectors Holdings Inc. et al., No. 8:26-cv-00897, before Judge John W. Holcomb in the Central District of California. The four defendants are Collectors Holdings, PSA, SGC and Beckett. The original complaint was filed April 14, 2026. Plaintiff's counsel is Daniel J. Mogin and Timothy Z. LaComb of Mogin Law LLP, according to Value Added Resource. In August the plaintiffs amended the complaint. The amendment added two collectors, Erick Azarian of California and Andrew Fedynyshyn of Pennsylvania, plus claims under California's Unfair Competition Law. The case's central allegation is that Collectors used its February 2024 purchase of SGC and its December 2025 purchase of Beckett to entrench PSA's dominance. The original complaint asked for treble, compensatory and punitive damages, an injunction against carrying out either acquisition, and divestiture of SGC and Beckett so that each operates independently.

Timeline: what Collectors said, and what the complaint later alleged

The left column records what Collectors announced at each step, or what independent outlets reported at the time. The right column records what the plaintiffs later alleged. The right column has not been tested in court.

DateWhat Collectors said, or what was reported at the timeWhat the complaint alleges, or what the court record shows
Feb. 29, 2024Collectors announced it was acquiring SGC. It said SGC "will continue to operate independently within the Collectors portfolio and be led by its current management team." SGC's Peter Steinberg said "SGC will remain an independent grading brand and no changes are contemplated." (Sports Collectors Digest)The original complaint alleges that SGC prices rose 20% after the deal and that turnaround times rose by as much as 400%.
July 24, 2025SI reported that Steinberg was stepping down as SGC president "effective immediately." It also reported that PSA President Ryan Hoge would oversee authentication and grading at Collectors. (SI)The amended complaint alleges that SGC's monthly volume fell from about 150,000 cards in July 2025 to 50,000 in October.
July to Sept. 2025GemRate data reported by SI showed SGC grading 143,000 sports cards in July, 112,000 in August and 56,000 in September. SI paraphrased Hoge as saying SGC would become a "boutique" grading brand. (SI)The amended complaint alleges that SGC's lowest price rose from $15 to $18, that its expedited service rose from $40 to $150, and that its turnaround estimates grew to 40-50 business days.
Dec. 15, 2025Collectors announced a definitive agreement to acquire Beckett. It said Beckett "will remain an independent brand within the Collectors family of companies," that "There will be no change in pricing as a part of this acquisition," and that "Orders at PSA and Beckett will continue to be processed normally." (Collectors) ESPN reported that the monetary terms were "not made available." (ESPN)The amended complaint alleges that Beckett's in-person card-show price rose from about $25 to $60.
Dec. 19, 2025Rep. Pat Ryan's office published a letter to FTC Chair Andrew N. Ferguson asking for an antitrust investigation. The letter says Collectors had consolidated "over 80% of grading volume, leaving only one independent competitor." (Rep. Ryan's office)The letter is separate from the lawsuit. It asks whether the roll-up strategy "violates Section 5 of the FTC Act" and whether a divestiture or unwinding is warranted.
Apr. 14, 2026Rasmussen filed the proposed class action.The complaint says Collectors "increased prices and decreased the quality of services" after each acquisition.
June 8, 2026Collectors moved to dismiss the case and to compel arbitration and stay it. A hearing was originally set for Sept. 11. (Value Added Resource)The court did not rule on these motions before the complaint was amended.
Aug. 3, 2026The parties filed a joint stipulation to amend the complaint. (Value Added Resource)The amendment added Azarian and Fedynyshyn as plaintiffs, along with UCL claims and the new price figures listed above.
Sept. 21, 2026Collectors filed renewed motions to compel individual arbitration and to dismiss the amended complaint.The motions are pending.
Dec. 11, 2026Value Added Resource reported on Sept. 23 that the hearing on the renewed motions is set for this date.Hearing dates can move. Check the docket before relying on it.

The SGC volume numbers are worth reading side by side. GemRate's independent count reported by SI (143,000 in July 2025, 56,000 in September) and the complaint's alleged figures (about 150,000 in July, 50,000 in October) point the same way. That alone doesn't prove an antitrust violation. Collectors' position is that the decline reflects a deliberate move to a smaller SGC. In October 2025, before any lawsuit, GemRate founder Ryan Stuczynski told SI: "We continue to believe SGC will settle into grading 30,000-40,000 cards per month in the near future."

Allegations versus findings

All of the following come from the plaintiffs, as reported by Value Added Resource. None has been tested or found true by a court.

  • Before the deals, PSA had about 72% of grading volume, CGC about 18%, SGC about 5% and Beckett about 3%. Collectors had about 80% afterward. (Alleged)

  • SGC's lowest price rose from $15 to $18, and its expedited service rose from $40 to $150. (Alleged)

  • SGC turnaround estimates grew to 40-50 business days. (Alleged)

  • Beckett's in-person card-show price rose from about $25 to $60. (Alleged)

  • When PSA suspended its Value tier in June, $74.99 temporarily became the lowest price for a new PSA submission. (Alleged)

  • A PSA 10 2024 Silver Prizm Drake Maye rookie roughly doubled in value from October 2025 to January 2026, then fell nearly 40% by March 2026. The complaint uses this to argue that a slower return cost the submitter money. (Alleged)

No court has found that Collectors violated antitrust law, and no court has ordered a divestiture.

The market-share fight

The complaint's share figures carry much of the case, and Collectors has attacked how they were calculated. In its June motion, Collectors argued that the complaint shows only that PSA graded 72% of the 26.6 million cards graded by PSA, CGC, SGC and Beckett, not 72% of a whole market. The dismissal motion called the deals "two small, unremarkable acquisitions" and "a textbook example of a procompetitive response, not an antitrust violation." It also called the complaint "long on rhetoric but devoid of substance" and labeled the plaintiffs' theory "post hoc ergo propter hoc."

Extreme close-up illustration of a sleeved foil card corner against the beveled edge of a plastic slab, with a hard rim of light and a blurred second slab in the dark background.

The September filing repeats the point. It says the 80% figure covers only four graders and doesn't say whether the volume is U.S.-only. It also says CGC graded 4.92 million cards in 2025, more than SGC and Beckett combined. Collectors argues that demand growth, not reduced competition, explains the higher prices. The filing, as quoted by Value Added Resource, says that "In a market experiencing explosive growth in demand while facing capacity constraints," rising prices and turnaround times are what basic economics would predict.

ESPN's December 2025 report on the Beckett deal offers a third reference point. Citing GemRate, ESPN put PSA at "more than 75%," CGC at "just over 18%" and Beckett at "nearly 3%." That snapshot came from neither party. It doesn't settle how a court should define the market. It does show that the figures that matter depend on which graders and which cards get counted.

The arbitration clause, and why it may decide the case first

Collectors argues that all three plaintiffs accepted versions of the Collectors User Agreement and that none opted out within the 30-day window. The agreement includes binding arbitration and a class-action waiver. According to the September filing, Collectors says the agreement applies retroactively, and it cites a 2025 California case that enforced it.

Athlon Sports' June analysis explains the order of rulings: "The court will likely rule on the arbitration motion first, as a victory there renders the dismissal question moot." In other words, if the claims belong in individual arbitration, the court may never reach whether the complaint states an antitrust claim.

Collectors has also pointed to the plaintiffs' own submission histories. Value Added Resource reported that Rasmussen and Azarian each allege submitting one card through PSA's Super Express service. Fedynyshyn says he has graded hundreds of cards with PSA since 2022. None of the three alleges submitting to SGC or Beckett.

A separate case takes a different approach to the clause. Funk v. Collectors Universe (D. Md., No. 1:26-cv-02933, filed July 28, 2026) brings civil RICO and consumer claims. It argues that people who submitted through intermediaries never accepted PSA's arbitration agreement and class waiver. That argument is being made in a different court and doesn't bind the Rasmussen judge.

What each outcome of the renewed motions could mean

A ruling may not come at the hearing itself. Judges often take motions under submission and rule later. With that caveat, these are the plausible paths.

Arbitration compelled. The named plaintiffs would have to pursue their damages claims one by one in arbitration, and no class would go forward in this court. The divestiture request would lose its main vehicle in this case. Collectors' grading prices and turnaround times wouldn't change because of the ruling.

Dismissal. If the court dismisses the amended complaint, it could allow the plaintiffs to amend again, as courts often do on a first ruling. A dismissal would mean the complaint failed to state a claim as written. It would not be a finding that Collectors' conduct was lawful in every respect.

Both motions denied. The case would move toward discovery, where both sides exchange documents and data. That stage could produce internal records on SGC and Beckett pricing. It would still be a long way from any judgment, damages or divestiture.

None of these outcomes would directly change the fees you pay or the graders available to you in the near term. Divestiture is a remedy at the end of a case, not something a ruling on these motions would order.

What it means for your grading decisions now

Don't time submissions around the lawsuit. Posted prices and turnaround times are set by the companies, not the court, and nothing pending on Dec. 11 changes them. Check each grader's current posted fees before you submit rather than relying on figures in court filings, which are allegations and may be out of date.

Overhead illustration of two graded slabs and a sleeved foil card on dark felt, beside an open shipping box with bubble wrap, a tape roll and a small postal scale, lit by a low desk lamp.

For a specific card, the useful question is whether grading adds more to your net sale proceeds than it costs. PureGrail's card grading break-even tool compares incremental net proceeds using the grading fee, shipping and marketplace costs you enter. It doesn't predict grades, current prices or returns, so use your own sold comps for the raw and graded values. If you're weighing PSA against CGC or another grader, run the same card through it once for each grader with that grader's actual fee and your realistic resale estimate.

The Drake Maye example in the complaint shows a real risk regardless of how the case ends. When a card's price is moving quickly, turnaround time is a cost. If a card is near a short-term peak, a slow tier can cost more than the fee difference to a faster one.

What to watch next

  • The ruling on the Sept. 21 renewed motions. Arbitration is expected to be decided first.

  • Whether the FTC takes any action in response to Rep. Ryan's December 2025 letter.

  • The separate Funk case in Maryland and Lichtman v. Collectors Universe (C.D. Cal., No. 8:26-cv-02048), which was filed in state court on July 21, 2026 and later removed. Collectors told The Athletic that the Lichtman claims are "without merit," according to Value Added Resource.

Sources

DISCLAIMER: PureGrail articles are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, or legal advice. Collectibles are speculative assets and values can decrease significantly. Always conduct your own research before buying or selling. Past price performance does not indicate future results.

Note: This article contains AI-assisted content and has been reviewed in our editorial workflow.

Share this
Share

Frequently asked questions

What is the PSA antitrust lawsuit about?

Rasmussen v. Collectors Holdings Inc. et al., filed April 14, 2026 in the Central District of California, alleges that Collectors used its purchases of SGC (2024) and Beckett (2025) to entrench PSA's dominance. The plaintiffs seek damages and divestiture of SGC and Beckett.

Has a court ruled that PSA or Collectors violated antitrust law?

No. No court has ruled on any motion in the case or found an antitrust violation. The market-share, price and turnaround figures in the complaint are allegations.

What is happening at the Dec. 11 hearing?

Value Added Resource reported on Sept. 23 that Collectors' renewed motions to compel individual arbitration and to dismiss the amended complaint are set for a Dec. 11 hearing. A ruling may come later than the hearing itself.

Why does the arbitration clause matter?

Collectors says all three plaintiffs accepted the Collectors User Agreement, which includes binding arbitration and a class-action waiver, and none opted out within 30 days. If the court agrees, the claims would go to individual arbitration and no class would proceed in court.

Will the lawsuit change PSA or SGC grading fees?

Nothing pending at the Dec. 11 hearing would directly change current fees or turnaround times. Divestiture is a remedy the plaintiffs seek at the end of a case, not something a ruling on these motions would order.

The Newsletter

Keep pulling smart.

Weekly market moves, grading tips, auction highlights.

DISCLAIMER: PureGrail articles are for informational and entertainment purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes financial, investment, or legal advice. Collectibles are speculative assets and values can decrease significantly. Always conduct your own research before buying or selling. Past price performance does not indicate future results.